A ListMerge's merged-away record is listed by ListDeletedQuery as an ordinary deletion, with a TimeDeleted one second earlier than the merge's own answer gave, and the surviving record keeps its TimeModified and EditSequence

Observed 2026-10-11 on QuickBooks Enterprise Solutions 24.0 (US), reporting qbXML 17.0.

After a ListMergeRq, QuickBooks lists the merged-away record in ListDeletedQueryRq as an ordinary deletion, with nothing to say it was a merge. The TimeDeleted it stores is one second earlier than the one in the merge's own answer. The surviving record keeps its TimeModified and EditSequence, so a modified-since query does not pick it up.

Two customers with no transactions were merged:

qbXML
<ListMergeRq>
  <ListMergeType>Customer</ListMergeType>
  <MergeFrom><ListID>80000028-1791743862</ListID><EditSequence>1791743862</EditSequence></MergeFrom>
  <MergeTo><ListID>80000029-1791743863</ListID><EditSequence>1791743863</EditSequence></MergeTo>
</ListMergeRq>

QuickBooks answered, with the names left out here:

qbXML
<ListMergeRs statusCode="0" statusSeverity="Info" statusMessage="Status OK">
<ListMergeType>Customer</ListMergeType>
<MergedFrom>
<ListID>80000028-1791743862</ListID>
<TimeDeleted>2026-10-11T11:38:52-08:00</TimeDeleted>
</MergedFrom>
<MergedTo>
<ListID>80000029-1791743863</ListID>
<TimeCreated>2026-10-11T11:37:43-08:00</TimeCreated>
<TimeModified>2026-10-11T11:37:43-08:00</TimeModified>
<EditSequence>1791743863</EditSequence>
</MergedTo>
</ListMergeRs>

A ListDeletedQueryRq for ListDelType Customer then answered status 0 with one ListDeletedRet for 80000028-1791743862, with TimeDeleted 2026-10-11T11:38:51-08:00. With FromDeletedDate set to the merge answer's 11:38:52-08:00 it answered status 1, nothing found. From 11:38:51-08:00 it found the record. A CustomerQueryRq for the survivor answered the TimeModified and EditSequence it had before the merge.

What to do

If your application keeps a copy of a list current with modified-since and deleted-since queries, treat a merged-away record like any other deletion. Take your deleted-since starting point from ListDeletedRet's TimeDeleted, never from the merge's answer, or the deletion is missed. Do not expect the surviving record to show up as modified after a merge.

Not observed

  • Merging records that have transactions, and whether that changes the survivor's TimeModified.
  • List types other than customers, and customers with jobs.
  • Whether a ListDelRq's answer differs from ListDeletedRet by the same second.

QuBe Sync is a JSON API for QuickBooks Desktop that is built on what these findings show.