A payment applied to an invoice, a credit applied from a credit memo, a deposit taking a payment, or an InvoiceMod changing an amount or the date moves the other transaction's TimeModified but leaves its EditSequence
Observed 2026-10-09 on QuickBooks Enterprise Solutions 24.0 (US), reporting qbXML 17.0.
When one transaction changes another through a link, QuickBooks moves the other transaction's TimeModified but leaves its EditSequence. That happens to an invoice when a payment is applied to it, to a credit memo when a payment applies its credit, to payments when a deposit takes them, and to the payments and credit memos applied to an invoice when an InvoiceMod changes a line's amount or the invoice's date. Intuit describes EditSequence as changing "every time the object is changed", so both were expected to move.
An invoice added at 17:16:07 and paid in full at 17:17:33 answered:
<TxnID>4F4E-1791591367</TxnID>
<TimeCreated>2026-10-09T17:16:07-08:00</TimeCreated>
<TimeModified>2026-10-09T17:17:33-08:00</TimeModified>
<EditSequence>1791591367</EditSequence>
The TimeModified is the payment's, and the EditSequence is still the add's. An InvoiceMod sent with that original EditSequence after payments and credits had been applied answered status 0.
A payment applied to an invoice read back like this after an InvoiceMod changed two line rates, leaving the subtotal at 120.00:
<TxnID>4FA2-1791608696</TxnID>
<TimeCreated>2026-10-09T22:04:56-08:00</TimeCreated>
<TimeModified>2026-10-09T22:05:36-08:00</TimeModified>
<EditSequence>1791608696</EditSequence>
Whether the total changes does not decide it. An InvoiceMod that changed a line's amount or the TxnDate moved the applied payment and credit memo to its time. One that changed only the Memo or a line's Desc, or sent the lines back unchanged, left them alone.
What to do
Keep using the EditSequence you hold for an invoice, credit memo or payment after something is applied to it or it is deposited; it stays current. If you sync by ModifiedDateRangeFilter, expect an invoice to come back after a payment, a payment after a deposit, and payments and credit memos after their invoice's amounts or date change, with no change to their EditSequence. Compare the EditSequence, not the TimeModified, to decide whether your own copy of the record is stale.
Not observed
- A credit applied by an
InvoiceAdd'sSetCredit. - A
DepositModthat adds or drops a payment, and deleting a deposit. - Other
InvoiceModchanges, such as the customer, terms or due date. - Whether a
ReceivePaymentModorCreditMemoModmoves the invoice it is applied to.
QuBe Sync is a JSON API for QuickBooks Desktop that is built on what these findings show.